Milwaukee Wedding Cake and Desserts
Now a days, wedding cake and dessert can be whatever you want it to be! Don’t like or want cake, maybe a pie is more up your alley? Don’t want the traditional cake cutting, and would rather bite into a HUGE custom made donut? OKAY!
You do you and make sure your dessert reflects who you are as a couple. Enjoy all of my fantastic wedding dessert selections below. I cant pick a favorite, truly, you will love them all!
“Your dream will come true, whether it's a classic design or a whimsical novelty cake.” And it is true! Every wedding I have worked with CeCe Baker (yes you read that right) has been fantastic. Truly, her work is irreplaceable and stunning.
Oh do I have two amazing options for you! Ice cream is always a crowd pleaser… and my first one will make custom… YES CUSTOM ice cream flavors based on your love of flavor, treats or general taste.
Here is a primary example. I LOVE apple pie and since my birthday is in October, I prefer Apple Pie over birthday cake. For my 40th birthday, Jamie, my dear friend who owns Sweet Tooth Grin, made me a custom apple pie ice cream! It was gone by the end of the night… and for good reason! Ask me more about it when we meet… I could go on and on and on! it was THAT good!
Purple Door is Milwaukee’s premier ice cream shop and they really care about their community and couples! Donna is a dream to work with and will assist you in deciding your flavors and creations to match your unique day. Looking for a fun, and different wedding dessert, don’t hesitate to reach out!
I know, I know it sounds silly, but it is a great idea and fun!
You will have your guests saying… “these really came from a gas station?!”
Order some bulk items from Kwik Trip.
To order bulk bakery items from Kwik Trip, use the Kwik Rewards app's "Order Ahead" feature for smaller bulk orders or, for very large quantities (like dozens of Glazers), ask for a store leader/kitchen leader at least a week in advance to get potential volume discounts, as staff may need special training for large orders. Be sure to check the app's availability for specific bakery items, and for very large needs, in-store coordination with management is key for the best service and pricing.
Yes, another woman owned business and this has to be one of my favorite unique ideas. Do you want the tradition of cutting something, but don’t like cake? And you want the best alternate option? If the answer is YES, then please check out Honey Pie… I am already drooling and throwing bows to get my slice at your wedding!
We all have that “Cranky Uncle”, yes you know the one.
Well don’t fear, this experience will not be like Thanksgiving dinner with Uncle Bob. It will be a delightful experience filled with sweet treats and delicious, alternative wedding dessert options. Did I mention, you can customize a HUGE donut to fit your wedding dreams and bite into for grandma’s photo. And mine of course!
Originally Published: Mar 23, 2022 Updated: May 27th, 2026